Important Things to Know About Humans

I. The Basics  ↑

15. We forge identities for ourselves that provide meaning in our lives.

Each human develops an identity for themselves, and it is these identities that make our lives meaningful.

Our identity answers the questions: Who am I? How do I fit in? Where do I belong? Who are my people? How do I contribute? Why am I here?

This drive to establish and maintain identity is probably the primary determinant for most of our human behavior.

This assertion appears counterintuitive because identity by itself seems to have little intrinsic value, and directly satisfies few if any of our most basic needs.

And yet identity is a powerful proxy for our ability to acquire those things that do have intrinsic value, such as food, shelter, respect and love.

For most other species, an organism’s identity is largely determined by its genetic makeup.

But with humans our genes provide only a large range of possibilities and capabilities, with all the most important elements of our identities determined after our birth, through a process of gradual development and discovery and association.

As just one example, all humans have the capacity for language, but which language we learn (and so, which set of fellow humans we can easily live and work with) is determined, not by our genes, but by our upbringing.

A human without any identity is something like a computer without an operating system: it presents lots of interesting possibilities, but it’s not actually functional in any meaningful way.

Our human identities seem to be composed of elements from the following sources:

  1. Our relationships with family and friends (our kith and kin);
  2. Our associations with other humans, and the group(s) to which we belong, and the cultural elements that we share (our tribes);
  3. Our participation in groups working together to achieve a shared goal (our teams);
  4. The features of the land on which we were raised, and on which we reside (our homeland);
  5. The expertise we have acquired, and the set of tools with which we have become proficient (our trade);
  6. Our accomplishments, especially when tied to one or more of the first five elements.

Identities ideally help to connect the four realms we each need to manage: the physical world, our social relationships, our physical bodies and our inner worlds.


Words from Others on this Topic

We are desperately needy. We need a place to stand, and a people to stand with, and a cause to stand for.

Ed Zeiders

A meaningful activity is oriented toward a goal, one that, if accomplished, would have an impact on the world — and this usually means that it has an impact on other people. This activity extends across a significant portion of one’s life and has some structure — it’s the sort of thing that one can tell a story about. It often connects to religion and spirituality and often connects to flow (leading to the experience of self-loss) and often brings you into close contact with other people and is often seen as morally virtuous — but none of these additional features are essential.

Paul Bloom, 2022, from the book The Sweet Spot

As Nietzsche put it, if you have a why to live, you can bear almost any how. A meaningful life can be extremely satisfying even in the midst of hardship, whereas a meaningless life is a terrible ordeal no matter how comfortable it is.

Yuval Noah Harari, 2015, from the book Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind

We are all aware, if we have ever tried it, how empty and ghostly is a life lived for a long while in absolute solitude. Free me from my fellows, let me alone to work out the salvation of my own glorious self, and surely (so I may fancy) I shall now for the first time show who I am. No, not so; on the contrary I merely show in such a case who I am not. I am no longer friend, brother, companion, co-worker, servant, citizen, father, son; I exist for nobody; and ere-long, perhaps to my surprise, generally to my horror, I discover that I am nobody.

Josiah Royce, from the lecture “Lecture on Hegel

Ultimately, man should not ask what the meaning of his life is, but rather must recognize that it is he who is asked. In a word, each man is questioned by life; and he can only answer to life by answering for his own life; to life he can only respond by being responsible.

Victor Frankl, 1946, from the book Man's Search for Meaning

Relevant Reference Models

Meaning - DRAMMA


Next: 16. We are fallible